http://www.shootfortheedit.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=1575

 

:tflaugh

 

Wow... cant wait.

lol to everything in that post

 

people are dickwads, aren't they

Nowhere did I see him mention PASSION AND HEART. I'm supremely pissed.

nah nah nah nah Dickwads

Nowhere did I see him mention PASSION AND HEART. I'm supremely pissed.

First Starscream, now this.

So is he saying the people who claim to have read the script already are full of it? Hahaha.

I sometimes wonder if all of the blame heaped on Bay would have been lessened if Don Murphy hadn't originally whipped the fanboyz into a frenzy by telling them to pretty much expect a "G1" movie.

 

Would the changes have been better accepted if initially everyone was told to expect something different, but with concepts that were undenialbly "based" on G1?

So is he saying the people who claim to have read the script already are full of it? Hahaha.

 

He means the final script, which hasn't been leaked, at this point.

 

 

I sometimes wonder if all of the blame heaped on Bay would have been lessened if Don Murphy hadn't originally whipped the fanboyz into a frenzy by telling them to pretty much expect a "G1" movie.

 

Would the changes have been better accepted if initially everyone was told to expect something different, but with concepts that were undenialbly "based" on G1?

 

I think we'd still see some outrage, but maybe not as much.

 

Not to lock another thread, or anything, but I do think we're getting a damn G1 movie. Ops, Megs, Bumbles, Screamer, the Whitwicky family, transforming into modern cars/military vehicles,

 

But G1 means something else to other people, I guess.

Not to contribute to tangenting another thread, but:

I sometimes wonder if all of the blame heaped on Bay would have been lessened if Don Murphy hadn't originally whipped the fanboyz into a frenzy by telling them to pretty much expect a "G1" movie.

Probably much less, but like Hobbes said, still some. My perception has been that Murphy is the most traditional, Bay wants what he feels is realistic and suited for his action, Bonaventura seems to have pushed for flash and the big-name voice actors, and Spielberg only wants a human story about "a boy and his car" (like he wanted Last Crusade to be about Indy and his dad). The director is typically the one with final say on creative decisions. And Bay & Bonaventura both seem concerned about avoiding any perception of "stupid, silly toy movie."

 

Would the changes have been better accepted if initially everyone was told to expect something different, but with concepts that were undenialbly "based" on G1?

I have to think so. I loved Evolutions: HoS since it was obviously G1 designs yet pitched as "off continuity". If the concepts are undeniably based on G1, you don't need to convince anyone of it because it'll be obvious at a mere glance.

I sometimes Would the changes have been better accepted if initially everyone was told to expect something different, but with concepts that were undenialbly "based" on G1?

 

I think we'd still see some outrage, but maybe not as much.

Undoubtedly, but I'm just wondering if people had been "prepped" to accept it a bit more. After all, most of the fandom seems to accept almost everyone looking completely different in each new cartoon.