VS

Scourge. Grimlock would rush into battle, but Scourge would use tactics and kick his ass.  Scourge also conquered a whole planet. That Fidel Castro.

gatta go with flame convoy

if it werent for the damn cyber planet keys grimmy.  Unfortuneatly scourge has and unfair gimmick based advantage. I Dont worrie though grimlock will out live him in tf histroy :tfevil

went with scourge...like it was said before, he would outsmart grim

If you don't count the popularity factor (or the whole, "Grimlock's my favorite character" thing, right, Me Grimlock No Bozo, Me King?) and actually think who would win in battle, Scourge is the obvious choice.

Yeah, I think he's the only one who voted for poor Grimmy.

Scourge could stil win without the Cyber key, for he has the BFA.

lol i voted for grimlock as well......they can both blow fire, which i think would lead to some climactic "flame" dual where they both shoot blasts of flames at each other which meet and create a massive explosion.

 

Grimlock is more ruthless, he'd transform into his t-rex form and snap scourge's extra dragon heads off with his jaws.  And if you compare the sizes of the transformers, grimlock would probably be roughly the size of Master Megatron (as grimlock was always taller than Prime in the g1 show) which is bigger than Scourge.

 

Great Sword fight would also ensue with Grim's Energo-Blade and Flame Convoy's Tail-Axe.

 

--------Grimlock Wins 7 out of 10 times---------

Though I really do like Grimlock, and trust me, I really do like him, Scourge wins.

 

Like Beast Megatron said, if you really thought about it, Scourge would win.  I mean, Grimlock is a decently smart warrior/commander, but he doesn't necessarily think it through too thorougly, Scourge looks at the outcomes of the situation depending on who would win (if x then y, but if a, then b). Taking that into consideration, and the advantage of a Cyber Key, I'd have to say Scourge/Flame Convoy would kick Grimmy's ass.