BW Megatron.

 

Best Megatron Ever.

Either Optimus Primal or Armada-Energon Megatron.

Rodimus Prime

I too vote for G1 Optimus Prime. He proved his ability as the Autobot leader time and again. The loyality of the Autobots to him was rarely questioned. IMO he is the best version of Prime. The BW Prime, never struck a cord with me. I do acknowledge his leadership prowess, but I prefer G1 Prime over him.

:tfevil Grimlock was the best leader! Not Prime or Megatron.

I chose G1 Megatron. I liked the fact that he always had some scheme to destroy the autobots. Kind of like Dr. Evil. :tftongue

My initial reaction was G1 Prime, but I had to vote for Energon Megatron due to his pure, ruthless tactics for getting what he wants. He treats his minions (execpt for Skorpionok) well.

Where is

Rodimus Prime

Fort Max

Star Saber

G1 Optimus was a good leader but all of the Autobots just fallowed him none really challenged him.

 

Good point, but the Autobots in G1 respected Optimus too much to challange him. I'd say that made him a great leader.